Home education, Section 19 and EOTAS: who's responsible for your child's education when school isn't working?

Three routes that sound alike, are often mixed up, and lead to very different places for your child and your family

(Before anything else: nothing in the SEND reforms has changed the law yet. Everything in this piece is based on the law as it stands today. There's a section near the end on what the Government has proposed for EOTAS.)

A child hasn't been able to get into school for most of the term. There's a meeting, and somewhere in the middle of it, someone kindly suggests that home education might take the pressure off for a while. A few weeks later, a form arrives to sign, or the family writes a short email to the school saying they'll keep their child at home "for now". Not long after that, a letter comes from the council's elective home education team, and the family realise, with a sinking feeling, that the council now sees them as the people responsible for arranging and paying for their child's education.

That family is a composite, drawn from patterns I see again and again in my work, and it's one of the most common and most avoidable situations I come across. Part of the reason it happens is that three quite different things get talked about as though they were interchangeable: elective home education, education arranged under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996, and education otherwise than at school (EOTAS) through an Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP). They can all look similar from the outside, because in each of them a child may be learning at home or with tutors. The difference is in who is responsible for making it happen and paying for it, and that difference shapes everything that follows.

The three routes at a glance

  • Elective home education: the parent chooses it, and the parent arranges and pays for it. The legal basis is section 7 of the Education Act 1996, and the child doesn't need an EHCP.

  • Section 19 education: the council must arrange it when the legal test is met, and the council arranges and pays for it. The legal basis is Section 19 of the Education Act 1996, and the child doesn't need an EHCP.

  • EOTAS: the council decides it, or the SEND Tribunal on appeal, and the council arranges and pays for it. The legal basis is section 61 of the Children and Families Act 2014, and the child does need an EHCP.

A useful way to think about it is a household repair. If you decide to fix your own boiler, you choose the engineer, you pay them, and if they don't turn up, that's yours to sort out. If you rent and your landlord is responsible for the boiler, the repair is theirs to arrange and pay for, whoever ends up doing the work. Elective home education is the first situation. Section 19 and EOTAS are both versions of the second, with the council in the landlord's position.

Elective home education

Under section 7 of the Education Act 1996, parents must make sure their child receives a suitable education "either by regular attendance at school or otherwise". Elective home education (often shortened to EHE) is when a parent chooses the "otherwise" and takes on responsibility for arranging and funding that education themselves. It doesn't mean a parent has to teach their child personally or follow the National Curriculum, and many families who choose it do so positively and thrive. The Department for Education's guidance on elective home education sets out how it works, with separate guides for parents and for councils.

What this means for families is that elective home education is a choice, and it should only ever be made as a choice. A child usually comes off a school roll when a parent tells the school in writing that they're educating their child at home, which is why an email saying "we'll keep them at home for now" can carry far more weight than a family intended. Contact, the charity for families with disabled children, is clear that a school cannot force you to take your child off the roll, even when it's suggested as being in your child's interests.

There are a few things worth knowing before making that decision:

  • Returning to school isn't automatic. Your child's place may not be held open, and getting back into the same school, or any school, can mean making a fresh application.

  • If your child has an EHCP, the plan doesn't simply disappear. The council still has to maintain and review it. Under section 42(5) of the Children and Families Act 2014, though, the council's duty to secure the special educational provision in the plan doesn't apply where parents have made suitable alternative arrangements themselves, which in practice can leave families funding support the council would otherwise have had to provide.

  • The rules are changing. The Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 will introduce a register of children not in school in every council area, and will require council consent before a child at a special school, or a child subject to certain child protection processes, can be withdrawn to be home educated. These parts are being brought in gradually, so it's worth checking the current position on GOV.UK. Even now, a child placed in a special school by the council usually can't be removed from its roll without the council's consent.

If you never meant to choose home education and your child has been recorded that way, it's worth asking the council to confirm in writing who it understands to be arranging your child's education, and under what power or duty. That simple question often brings the confusion into the open.

Section 19 of the Education Act 1996

Section 19 of the Education Act 1996 requires councils to arrange suitable education for any child of compulsory school age who, "by reason of illness, exclusion from school or otherwise", may not receive suitable education unless those arrangements are made. It applies whether or not a child has an EHCP. The education must be full-time, unless the child's physical or mental health means full-time education wouldn't be in their best interests, and "suitable" means efficient education suited to the child's age, ability, aptitude and any special educational needs.

The word "otherwise" is broad, and it can include children who can't attend because of anxiety, trauma or burnout. It's important to be clear, though, that difficulty attending doesn't on its own settle the question. The test is whether your child would actually receive a suitable education without the council stepping in, which is why evidence of what's stopping them accessing school carries so much weight. In R (LB) v Surrey County Council (2022), the High Court looked at whether education was, in reality, available and accessible to the child, and found the council had failed in its Section 19 duty. A more recent case, R (KGH) v North Tyneside Council (2026), shows the other side, where the council had concluded that suitable education remained available at the child's school, and it's a reminder that each case turns on its own facts and evidence.

Where a child can't attend because of their health, the Department for Education's statutory guidance for children who cannot attend school because of health needs says councils should arrange education as soon as it's clear the child will be away for 15 school days or more, whether in one go or added up over the year. Those 15 days are a planning point for health needs rather than a waiting period every family has to sit through first.

If what's offered under Section 19 isn't suitable, for example a generic online package your child can't engage with, the council hasn't met its duty simply by offering it. Section 19 education is arranged and funded by the council, and your child stays on the school roll unless there's a separate reason for them to come off it.

Section 42 of the Children and Families Act 2014

For children with an EHCP, there's another layer. Section 42 of the Children and Families Act 2014 requires the council to secure the special educational provision set out in Section F of the plan. The High Court confirmed in R (HXN) v London Borough of Redbridge (2024) that this duty is absolute and sits with the council rather than the school, and that trying to commission provision isn't the same as actually delivering it.

There's a practical catch when a child can't get into school. Much of the provision in a plan is often written with a school setting in mind, such as support in lessons or a small-group intervention, and it doesn't automatically move with the child when they're at home. If your child's plan no longer fits where they are actually learning, it's worth asking for an early or emergency review so the plan can be looked at again, alongside asking what Section 19 education will be arranged in the meantime.

Education otherwise than at school (EOTAS)

EOTAS is when the special educational provision in a child's EHCP is arranged somewhere other than a school or college, such as at home, in the community, or through a mix of tutors, therapists and activities. Under section 61 of the Children and Families Act 2014, a council may arrange this where it is satisfied that it would be inappropriate for the provision to be made in a school or college, and it must consult the parent first. You'll sometimes see it called EOTIS, which is the term the SEND Tribunal and IPSEA use because it matches the wording of the Act more closely.

EOTAS isn't home education. It's a bespoke package written into the EHCP, which the council must secure under Section 42 just like any other provision in the plan. The Upper Tribunal has explained how this works in practice:

  • In Derbyshire County Council v EM and DM (2019), it explained why a plan doesn't always have to name a school in Section I when a child's provision is wholly outside one, although a blank Section I on its own doesn't make an arrangement lawful EOTAS.

  • In NN v Cheshire East Council (2021), it explained how to look at each part of a child's provision when deciding whether it would be inappropriate to make it in a school.

Once EOTAS is in a plan, the council's duty to deliver it is as strong as for any other provision. In R (L) v Hampshire County Council (2024), the council accepted it had breached that duty after long gaps in a child's EOTAS package, and the court ordered it to secure the provision.

For many children who have been out of school for a long time and need a more flexible, interest-led approach, EOTAS can be what finally makes learning possible again. It can also leave families feeling they've become the education department, managing tutors and cancellations on top of everything else. Ofsted and the Care Quality Commission's thematic review Beyond the classroom looked at the experiences of children with SEND who are not in school, and Special Needs Jungle's report on it describes how one area helped families manage EOTAS budgets and check activities against children's needs. It's reasonable to ask your council who will coordinate providers, who deals with cancellations, and who checks that what's on paper is reaching your child. If a personal budget is part of the package, IPSEA's guide to personal budgets and direct payments explains who books and pays for what.

How the routes fit together

Section 19 and EOTAS answer two different questions, and both can arise for the same child at the same time. Section 19 is about what education your child can actually access right now. EOTAS is about what longer-term special educational provision their EHCP needs to set out. A council deciding whether EOTAS is appropriate, or a family waiting for a Tribunal hearing, doesn't mean your child should be left without education in the meantime. Special Needs Jungle has a helpful side-by-side comparison of Section 19 and EOTAS if you'd like to see them laid out together.

In practice, it can help to ask the council two separate questions in writing: what education can my child actually access now, and what provision does their plan need to set out for the longer term?

What the Government has proposed for EOTAS

In July 2026, the Department for Education consulted on changes to EOTAS under the SEND reforms. The consultation closed on 18 September 2026, and the Government intends to make changes through the Education for All Bill, with any changes coming into effect from 2029/30. Until then, the current law stays in place, and councils can still arrange EOTAS under section 61 where school-based provision would be inappropriate.

Here's what's known, what isn't, and my reading of it:

  • What the consultation proposed: the Government said it would seek views on protecting existing EOTAS arrangements in 2029/30 for children of secondary school age and older until they leave education. For the smaller number of children of early years and primary school age with EOTAS, it proposed reassessing their needs at the end of primary school.

  • What isn't known yet: what the Government will decide after the consultation, what will be in the Education for All Bill, and how EOTAS would work for children who don't fit one of the proposed national Specialist Provision Packages.

  • My reading, following IPSEA's: in its consultation response, IPSEA warns that the proposals would move the detail of a child's EOTAS provision out of the legally enforceable EHCP and into a new Individual Support Plan with no equivalent duty on anyone to deliver it, and would remove parents' right to challenge EOTAS decisions at the SEND Tribunal. It argues that the existing section 61 test should stay, with EOTAS provision still specified in an EHCP. Those concerns are ones I share.

That's a big part of why understanding the difference between these routes today is so useful: the clearer it is who is responsible for your child's education under the current law, the better placed families are to make sure it's in place now.

Questions worth asking

  • Who does the council understand to be arranging my child's education at the moment, and under what power or duty? Can you confirm that in writing?

  • If my child can't currently attend school, has the council considered its duty under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996, and what education will be arranged, from when?

  • If my child has an EHCP, how is each part of Section F being secured while they can't attend, and does the plan need an early review?

  • If EOTAS is agreed, who will coordinate providers, deal with cancellations and check that the education agreed on paper is reaching my child?

This piece is general information about the law, not legal advice about your child's situation, so if you're unsure what applies to you, it's worth getting advice before you act, especially before deciding to take your child off a school roll.

Home education can be a positive choice, and for some families it's exactly the right one. It should be a choice made with full information, rather than a responsibility a family finds they've taken on without realising, at the point when their child most needs the council to meet its duties.

Questions families often ask

Is EOTAS the same as home education?

No. Elective home education is when a parent chooses to arrange and pay for their child's education. EOTAS is special educational provision that the council arranges outside a school or college through a child's EHCP, and which the council must secure.

Can my child's school make me take them off the roll?

No. A school can suggest it, but it can't force you to deregister your child. It's worth getting information and advice before deciding, because coming off the roll can change who is responsible for your child's education.

Does Section 19 apply if my child doesn't have an EHCP?

Yes. Section 19 of the Education Act 1996 applies to any child of compulsory school age who may not receive suitable education unless the council makes arrangements, whether or not they have an EHCP.

What happens to my child's EHCP if we home educate?

The council still has to maintain and review the plan. Its duty to secure the provision in the plan doesn't apply where parents have made suitable arrangements themselves, which can mean families end up funding support the council would otherwise have provided.

I took my child off the school roll under pressure. Can I undo it?

You can apply for your child to go back to school, though their old place isn't guaranteed and it may mean a fresh application. In the meantime, if your child can't access suitable education, you can ask the council to consider its duty under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996, and to confirm in writing who it understands to be responsible for their education.

Who pays for EOTAS?

The council. EOTAS is special educational provision written into your child's EHCP, which the council must secure. Sometimes part of it is delivered through a personal budget, but that doesn't make families responsible for funding it.

If you need support now

These free resources are based on the law as it stands today:

Sources

Legislation and guidance

Case law

Reports, reform documents and explainers

Previous
Previous

"Fine in school": what a classroom can't show, and how to make sure it still counts

Next
Next

The Quiet Work of Recovery: What Autistic Burnout Can Teach Us About Rest