"Fine in school": what a classroom can't show, and how to make sure it still counts

Why so many children's needs only become visible at home, what the research says about it, and how families can make sure that evidence is weighed when decisions are made

(Before anything else: nothing in the SEND reforms has changed the law yet. Everything in this piece is based on the law as it stands today.)

There's a child who comes out of school at quarter past three looking much like everyone else. She waves to her friends, walks to the car, buckles her seatbelt, and then, somewhere between the school gate and the front door, everything she's been holding together all day comes apart. Some days it's tears that go on for an hour. Some days it's a slammed door and a long silence, and some days she simply lies on her bedroom floor and can't be reached until bedtime. When her parents raise it at school, the response is kind and sincere: "We don't see any of that here. In class, she's fine."

She's a composite, drawn from patterns I see in my work again and again, and the phrase her parents hear is one that almost every family I work with has heard at some point. It usually comes with others: "she holds it together really well", "he just needs to build resilience", "once they're in, they settle." These things are said honestly, by staff describing exactly what they see. The difficulty is that what they see is only part of the picture, and decisions about a child's support are very often made on that part alone.

This piece is about the rest of the picture: why so much of what children experience at school only shows up at home, what the research tells us about it, and how families can make sure it's taken into account when it counts.

Why some children fall apart at home after school

Most of the evidence used in SEND decisions comes from what adults can observe in school: attendance, attainment, behaviour, whether a child joins in, and whether they seem calm. These are real and useful things to know. They tell us what a child is able to show while they're at school, though, which isn't always the same as what being at school is asking of them.

Many neurodivergent children, particularly autistic children, get through the school day by masking, sometimes called camouflaging. Masking means hiding or holding back the things that come naturally, such as stimming, needing to move or needing a break, and copying the behaviour of the children around them so they don't stand out. Some children do this deliberately, but many have done it for so long that they don't notice they're doing it at all. In a classroom, masking can look like a quiet, compliant, well-behaved child who's getting on with their work.

An everyday comparison can help. Think about how most of us behave in a job interview: we sit up straight, smile, choose our words carefully and keep any nerves well hidden, and an interviewer might come away thinking we were completely relaxed. Then we get home and feel wrung out for the rest of the day. Now imagine that interview lasting six hours, five days a week, with no clear end date, and you get a sense of what school can be like for a child who's masking. The interviewer's impression isn't wrong exactly. It just tells you very little about what the day cost.

That cost has to go somewhere, and it tends to come out where a child finally feels safe enough to let go, which for most children is at home with the people they trust most. The meltdowns, shutdowns, exhaustion and dread on Sunday evenings are often the clearest signs of what school is asking of them. In my experience, the difference between home and school rarely means one account is wrong. Both are usually accurate, and the gap between them is itself important information about the child.

What the research says

This pattern is well documented. Studies with autistic girls have found that many describe camouflaging at school to try to fit in, and then stopping once they get home, with the exhaustion of a day spent camouflaging often linked to distress and difficult behaviour at home afterwards.

Researchers have also measured the gap directly. A 2024 study of nearly 400 autistic children and young people compared parents' and teachers' ratings of the same children's autistic traits. For girls, teachers reported noticeably fewer autistic characteristics than parents did, across several areas, and the researchers suggested this gap may reflect camouflaging in the school setting. Older children showed a bigger gap than younger ones.

Masking also comes at a cost to children's wellbeing. A study of more than 700 autistic children and young people found that camouflaging was linked with higher levels of anxiety and depression, and research with autistic girls who split their time between mainstream classes and a resource base found they masked most in the mainstream classroom and found it exhausting and distressing.

There's a link to belonging, too. A 2025 study of 72 autistic secondary students in mainstream schools in the UK and Ireland found that students who felt they belonged less at school camouflaged more, and that camouflaging helped explain the link between low belonging and higher anxiety. Two thirds of the students said they couldn't be their true self at school, often because they feared being judged, laughed at or bullied, and one asked a question that sums up a great deal: "do my friends only like the school me or the true me?"

The same study found that small, practical things helped students feel they could take the mask off: kind and understanding staff, friends with shared interests, permission to wear headphones, and access to a quiet space or hub. Many schools are already doing exactly this, and it makes a real difference.

Why short assessments can miss so much

Much of the professional evidence about a child is gathered in short windows: a classroom observation, a single appointment, an hour with an educational psychologist or a clinician in an unfamiliar room. In those settings, a child who masks may do everything they can to hold it together precisely because a new adult is watching and the situation feels high-stakes.

None of this means professional reports aren't valuable. Professionals bring training and expertise that families often rely on, and a good report can transform how a child is understood. It does mean that an observation is a snapshot, and that parents, who see their child across weeks, months and years, in every setting and at every time of day, hold evidence that no short observation can collect. A professional sees a moment, and a parent sees the pattern around it, including the hours or days it can take a child to recover from the appointment itself.

Research on autism assessment makes a similar point: the Ross, Grove and McAloon study found that older autistic young people showed a larger gap between parent-reported and clinician-observed autistic traits, which the authors said has implications for clinical assessment.

National clinical guidance recognises this too. NICE's guidance on recognising and diagnosing autism in under-19s says that where reports about a child and what's seen during an assessment don't match, professionals should consider gathering additional information from other sources, including observations in other settings such as home or school (recommendations 1.5.9 to 1.5.11).

It's worth being clear about what a home and school difference does and doesn't show. On its own, it doesn't prove one particular explanation, and there can be several. What it does show is that there's more to understand about the child, which is exactly the point families are usually trying to make.

What the law says about parents' evidence

The law already gives parents' knowledge real weight, even if it doesn't always feel that way in meetings:

  • Section 19 of the Children and Families Act 2014 requires councils, when carrying out their SEND duties, to have regard to the views, wishes and feelings of the child and their parent, and to the importance of them taking part as fully as possible in decisions. That doesn't decide how much weight every piece of evidence gets, but it does mean your views can't simply be set aside.

  • The threshold for an EHC needs assessment is deliberately low. Under section 36(8) of the Children and Families Act 2014, a council must assess if a child has or may have special educational needs, and may need special educational provision to be made through an Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP). Nothing in that test says the needs have to be visible in a classroom, and the separate decision about whether to issue a plan comes later.

  • Councils must seek parents' advice and information during an EHC needs assessment, under regulation 6 of the Special Educational Needs and Disability Regulations 2014. What you write is evidence, and it should be treated as such.

A recent Upper Tribunal decision from Wales shows both the possibilities and the limits here. The case concerned an 11-year-old autistic girl who was achieving well academically, and the Education Tribunal for Wales found that, because of masking, she had to work harder to keep up her presentation and achievements at school. The Upper Tribunal was careful to say that masking isn't a general basis for finding additional needs, and that there has to be evidence about the particular child. It still held that the tribunal had been entitled to reach its finding, based on the parents' evidence of anxiety symptoms at home, medical letters and an educational psychologist's observation of masking at school.

That case was decided under the Welsh system, which has its own law, though the lesson travels well. Saying that a child masks is rarely enough on its own; showing what masking looks like for this particular child, with evidence from home and from professionals who understand it, can carry real weight.

In England, the Upper Tribunal has also shown that a child's own perspective can't be skipped over. In TM and SM v Liverpool City Council (2024), it set aside a decision about the school named in a child's plan because it couldn't be shown that the First-tier Tribunal had considered the child's views about the proposed school, and sent that part back to be decided again. That case wasn't about masking, but it shows that what a child experiences, and how families evidence it, is part of what decision-makers are required to weigh.

Making the invisible visible

In practice, this means turning what you see at home into evidence that sits alongside what school sees. Some approaches families I work with have found helpful:

  • Keep a simple diary over several weeks. Note what happens before and after school, at weekends and during holidays: energy levels, mood, meltdowns or shutdowns, how long it takes your child to recover, and what seemed to help. The contrast between school days and holidays is often one of the clearest pieces of evidence there is.

  • Describe the impact, rather than only the behaviour. "She lies on her bedroom floor for two hours after school and can't eat dinner" tells a decision-maker far more than "she's tired", and it links what you see to what school is asking of her.

  • Include your child's views in whatever way works for them, whether that's words, drawings, a scale, a written note or something you record on their behalf. Children can sometimes say things about school at home that they would never say in a meeting.

  • Ask professionals to consider masking directly. If an assessment is being carried out, you can share your diary in advance and ask the professional to address the difference between home and school in their report, rather than relying only on what they observe.

  • Respond to reports in writing. If a report doesn't reflect what you see, you can ask for factual errors to be corrected and send your own written response, asking for it to be included with the evidence.

  • Bring school in alongside you. Many teachers recognise this pattern once they know what's happening at home, and a short note from school saying "we see a quiet, compliant child, and we're aware of what's happening after school" can be very powerful.

When a council refuses to assess, or an EHCP doesn't reflect needs that show up mainly at home, that decision can be challenged, whether through mediation, an appeal to the SEND Tribunal or a complaint. This piece is general information, not legal advice about your child's situation.

Why this is worth knowing now

The Government's SEND reform proposals would change how children's needs are identified and supported, with much more of the detail moving into plans written by schools. Those proposals aren't law yet. Whatever happens next, children who mask are among those most at risk of being missed by any system that relies mainly on what can be seen during the school day, and families' evidence of what happens beyond it is likely to be more important, not less.

A child who looks settled in class may well be doing their very best to stay that way, and that effort deserves to be seen and counted. Home is often the first place where what school costs a child becomes visible, and what families see there belongs in the evidence.

Questions families often ask

Why does my child fall apart at home when school says they're doing well?

Many neurodivergent children, particularly autistic children, mask at school, holding back their needs and copying the children around them so they don't stand out. That effort is exhausting, and it tends to come out where a child finally feels safe, which is usually at home. Research comparing parents' and teachers' reports, and studies with autistic girls, describe exactly this pattern.

Can I ask for an EHC needs assessment if school doesn't see any difficulties?

Yes. A parent can ask the council for an assessment directly. The legal test is whether your child has or may have special educational needs and may need special educational provision through an EHCP, and nothing in that test says the needs have to be visible in a classroom. Evidence of what happens at home is part of the picture the council should consider.

How can I show the council what happens at home?

Keep a simple diary over several weeks, describe the impact on your child rather than only the behaviour, include your child's own views in whatever way suits them, and ask professionals to address the difference between home and school in their reports.

The council refused an EHC needs assessment because my child is doing well academically. Can I challenge that?

Yes. Good grades don't settle whether a child has special educational needs, and the legal test doesn't require needs to show up in attainment or in the classroom. You can challenge a refusal to assess, including through mediation and an appeal to the SEND Tribunal, and the decision letter should tell you the deadlines.

My child has meltdowns every day after school. Is that normal?

Many children are tired after school, but daily meltdowns, shutdowns or hours of recovery are worth taking seriously as a sign of what the school day is costing your child. It's a reason to look more closely at what's happening during the day, and to share what you see at home with school and any professionals involved.

If you need support now

These free resources are based on the law as it stands today:

Sources

Previous
Previous

The False Divide Between Being Collaborative and Being Lawful

Next
Next

Home education, Section 19 and EOTAS: who's responsible for your child's education when school isn't working?