When Inclusion Hurts: For the Children Schools Don’t Yet Know How to Hold

Some children are described as "fine when they're here", while they start each day in tears or fall apart the moment they get home. This post looks at what children themselves say about mainstream school, what inclusion should really mean, what the law says about adjustments and placements, and what families can do when mainstream school is hurting their child.

Updated November 2026

Across England, many children are struggling to cope in mainstream school. Some start each morning in tears, others get through the day and collapse the moment they get home, and many are still described by school as "fine when they're here".

Parents are often reassured that this is "normal at that age", that separation anxiety will pass, and that the best thing to do is to keep getting them in. For a growing number of families, though, that reassurance no longer matches what they're seeing.

This post is for those families, and for the school staff who can see that something isn't working and want to understand why.

The children behind the headlines

This is for the children who are overwhelmed by environments that weren't built with them in mind; for the children who seem to "refuse school" when what they're really trying to escape is pain; and for the children who are praised for their resilience while quietly falling apart inside.

In their own way, these children are showing us what real inclusion would need to look like.

What children themselves say about mainstream school

When researchers ask autistic and neurodivergent young people directly, a consistent picture emerges.

A systematic review by Horgan, Kenny and Flynn brought together 33 studies of autistic pupils' experiences of mainstream secondary school. Recurring themes included the demands of the mainstream setting, the challenges of taking part socially, and the impact all of this had on pupils themselves. The review draws together pupils' accounts across many settings, rather than ranking one type of school above another.

In Mainstream is not for all, Craig Goodall spoke with twelve autistic young people in Northern Ireland. They drew a clear distinction between being academically able to do the work and being able to cope with the mainstream environment, and spoke about how much a sense of belonging affected them. Their experiences come from Northern Ireland, so they don't tell us anything about the law in England, although they echo what so many families here describe.

Closer to home, Fielding and colleagues (2025) interviewed 30 neurodivergent pupils aged 11 to 16 in UK mainstream secondary schools who were experiencing school distress. The young people described uncertainty, sensory and social barriers, and impacts that reached well beyond attendance.

Pupils also tell us what helps. Dimitrellou and Male asked pupils with SEND what makes a positive school experience, and their accounts are a helpful reminder that one child's priorities can be very different from another's, and that asking the child is often the best place to start.

Families' experiences add to this. In a study of family experiences of mainstream inclusion, Dunleavy and Sorte argued that how inclusion feels to the whole family should be part of how we judge whether it's working.

The problem with "fine"

"Inclusion" has become one of education's most used words, and one of its most misunderstood. Too often, it's treated as the same thing as attendance: being in the building, in the classroom and in the system.

Real inclusion is about safety. It's about a child being understood, supported and accepted for who they are, rather than for who the system needs them to be.

The Department for Education's own school belonging case studies (October 2026) looked at 16 mainstream schools selected for their success in building pupils' sense of belonging. The first of the five dimensions of belonging they identified was safety and security: a physically and psychologically safe environment where pupils can make mistakes without judgement. The schools also described individualised approaches for pupils with SEND, quiet spaces for regulation and giving pupils real influence over their experience. Those schools were chosen because their practice was working, so the study can't show that the same strategies will work for every child or every school, although it's encouraging to see belonging and safety placed at the heart of the conversation. I wrote more about this in Sitting in a classroom and belonging in it.

Sometimes, though, inclusion means admitting something uncomfortable: not every environment can be made safe for every child. No number of adaptations or reasonable adjustments can fully make up for a setting that overwhelms a child's sensory or emotional capacity day after day.

Having "offers on the table" doesn't help if a child can't get through the door to reach it.

Listening to the signal

When a child starts to struggle, the default response is often to focus on fixing attendance. Some families tell me they've been advised to make home less appealing, to avoid comforting their child, or to stay strong and keep pushing. What if the child's distress is a message to hear, rather than a behaviour to manage?

These children can be understood as a signal, showing us what happens when the needs of children who experience the world differently aren't built into how schools are designed and run.

They reveal the limits of an education system that has often been built around compliance and resilience, rather than safety and connection. They remind us that inclusion without safety can turn into endurance: being made to fit somewhere that still hurts.

It's worth saying clearly that many schools see this too. The school staff I work alongside often recognise exactly what's happening, try hard to adapt and advocate for the child, and then find themselves stuck with limited resources and council decisions they can't control.

A shift in perspective

While headlines often frame this as a crisis of attendance, many families and professionals see it as a crisis of safety. Children who can't manage school are usually trying to get away from pain, rather than trying to get away from learning.

Listening to them, and to the families who see what happens once the school gates close, protects children. It isn't being permissive.

When children are given safety, they often begin to recover, and from recovery can come learning, growth and trust, which are the real foundations of education.

What the law says

The law in England already offers several routes that can help when mainstream school is hurting a child. A few of the most useful:

  • Reasonable adjustments. Under the Equality Act 2010, schools must not discriminate against disabled pupils and must make reasonable adjustments, including providing auxiliary aids and services. Many autistic and neurodivergent children meet the Act's definition of disability. Adjustments might include a quiet place to go, a flexible start or end to the day, changes to uniform, a key adult, or alternatives to busy corridors and lunch halls.

  • SEN support. Under section 66 of the Children and Families Act 2014, mainstream schools must use their best endeavours to make sure the special educational provision a child needs is made.

  • An EHC needs assessment. If support at school isn't enough, you can ask the council for an assessment under section 36 of the Children and Families Act 2014. The question is whether your child has or may have special educational needs and may need provision through an EHCP. My EHC needs assessment toolkit walks you through it.

  • Choosing a school. If your child has an EHCP, section 39 lets you ask for a particular school, including a special school, and the council must name it unless one of a small number of exceptions applies. Section 33 gives children a strong right to mainstream education when that's what parents want, although it doesn't stop a family asking for a specialist setting. If you disagree with the school named in the plan, you can challenge it, including at the SEND Tribunal.

  • Attendance. The Department for Education's statutory guidance Working together to improve school attendance expects schools and councils to work with families to understand and remove barriers to attendance, including those linked to SEND or health needs, as a first step.

  • Reduced timetables should be short-term, agreed with you, time-limited and part of a clear plan, rather than an open-ended way of managing a child whose needs aren't being met.

  • When a child can't attend at all. Section 19 of the Education Act 1996 requires councils to arrange suitable education for children who, because of illness or otherwise, may not receive it without those arrangements. For some children, education otherwise than at school (EOTAS) through an EHCP is the arrangement that fits best.

This section is general information, not legal advice about your child's situation.

Practical steps when mainstream is hurting your child

  • Write down what you're seeing at home, including how your child is before and after school, at weekends and in the holidays. A simple diary can show patterns that school may never see.

  • Ask your child what's hardest and what helps, in whatever way works for them: talking, drawing, writing, choosing from options or pointing to parts of a school map or timetable.

  • Meet with school to agree specific adjustments, and ask for them to be written down and reviewed after a set time.

  • Ask for advice from professionals who know your child, such as an educational psychologist, occupational therapist, speech and language therapist or CAMHS, and ask them to consider what happens at home as well as at school.

  • Ask for an EHC needs assessment if support at SEN support level isn't enough.

  • If your child can't attend, ask the school and council in writing what education your child will receive, and whether the council has considered its duty under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996.

If your child is in burnout, my posts Beyond "school refusal" and The quiet work of recovery may help.

What the SEND reforms could mean for inclusion

The Government's Schools White Paper (February 2026) and the SEND reform proposals put a strong emphasis on including more children with SEND in mainstream schools. Many families would welcome mainstream schools that are more accessible, if that comes with the culture change, staffing, training and environmental changes that would make them feel safe.

There are real concerns, though, about what happens to children for whom mainstream isn't working. Under the proposals, as IPSEA and others have read them, the SEND Tribunal would no longer be able to name a school, only send the decision back to the council, and the detail of many children's support would move into school-written plans that can't be taken to the Tribunal, that the Ombudsman can't investigate and that nobody would have a clear legal duty to deliver. For most families, the main option would be complaining to the school that wrote the plan.

None of this has changed the law yet. My close reading of the White Paper, Reform or retreat?, and my free guide Your child's EHCP and the SEND reforms go into this in more detail, and you can write to your MP to ask them to protect the legal rights of children with SEND.

How I support families

I work with families whose children can't access school because their needs aren't being met, whether through autistic burnout, school distress (sometimes called emotionally based school avoidance, or EBSA) or school trauma. I help parents understand their child's rights under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996, build strong EOTAS packages and challenge local authority decisions. You can find out more, and check current availability, on my contact page.

What to remember

Real inclusion begins with listening: to children, to the families who see the whole picture, and to the many school staff who can see what isn't working. That's where change starts.

Questions families often ask

School says my child is fine, but they fall apart as soon as they get home. Why?

Many children hold things together at school, sometimes by masking, and release the stress once they're somewhere safe. What happens at home is important evidence of how your child is really coping, and it's worth recording and sharing with school and any professionals involved.

My autistic child is struggling in mainstream school. What are my options?

You can ask the school for specific reasonable adjustments and SEN support, ask the council for an EHC needs assessment, and, if your child has an EHCP, ask for a different school, including a specialist setting, to be named. If your child can't attend at all, the council may have a duty to arrange education under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996.

Can I ask for a special school in my child's EHCP?

Yes. You can ask for a particular school, including a special school, and the council must name it unless one of a small number of legal exceptions applies. If you disagree with the school named, you can challenge the decision, including at the SEND Tribunal.

School has told me to make home less appealing so my child wants to go in. Is that right?

Many families are given this advice, and many find it makes things harder. If your child's distress is linked to unmet needs at school, making home less comfortable doesn't address the cause. It's reasonable to ask instead what adjustments and support school can put in place.

What does inclusion actually mean?

Inclusion is about a child feeling safe, understood and able to take part, rather than simply being in the building. For some children that can happen in mainstream with the right support, and for others it may need a different setting or arrangement.

If you need support now

These free resources are based on the law as it stands today:

Sources

Previous
Previous

Why SEND mediation Is (usually) worth it

Next
Next

How Think Tanks Manipulate Families to Justify Cutting SEND Support