Appealing an EHCP doesn't pause your child's right to an education

Why a school place your child can't get through the door of isn't the same as suitable education, and what you can do while you wait for a Tribunal hearing

(Before anything else: nothing in the SEND reforms has changed the law yet. Everything in this piece is based on the law as it stands today, and it applies to your child now.)

A family receives their child's final Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP), the legal document setting out a child's special educational needs and the help they must receive. It names the mainstream secondary school the child is on the roll of, the same school the child hasn't been able to walk into since the middle of Year 7. Much of the help described in the plan is vague, and the school named is one the child can't currently reach, so the family do what everyone tells them to do and appeal to the SEND Tribunal, the independent judge who decides disagreements about what an EHCP should say. A few weeks later the hearing date arrives, and it's 18+ months away.

This family is a composite, drawn from patterns I see again and again in my work rather than from any one family, though many of the families I work with will recognise every part of it. Being told to appeal a plan that doesn't fit is good advice. What families are rarely told is the answer to the obvious next question, which is what's supposed to happen to their child's education in the meantime.

The answers they do hear tend to sound something like this:

  • "The provision is available at the school."

  • "We have to follow the plan as it stands until the Tribunal decides."

  • "Whether your child attends is a separate issue."

  • "If you're unhappy with the school, you could always home educate."

Some families also start to hear about attendance procedures or fines, which can be frightening when a child is already struggling to cope. Schools are often caught in the middle of this, passing on the council's position while doing what they can for the child, and many of the schools I work with are as frustrated by it as the families are.

Here's the part families most need to hear: appealing your child's EHCP doesn't pause their right to a suitable education, and a school place your child can't get to doesn't, on its own, mean that right has been met.

What an appeal does, and what it doesn't change

An appeal is about what the plan should say: how your child's needs are described, what help they should get, and which school or setting should be named. While the Tribunal decides that, the plan the council issued stays in force, and so do the council's legal duties under it.

The most important of those comes from Section 42 of the Children and Families Act 2014. Once an EHCP is in place, the council must secure the special educational provision set out in Section F of the plan. That duty sits with the council rather than the school, it doesn't depend on the council's budget, and it carries on throughout an appeal. In plain terms, if your child's plan says they should have an hour of speech and language therapy every week, the council has to make sure that happens now, even while you're asking the Tribunal to improve the rest of the plan. (There's a narrow exception where parents have made their own suitable arrangements instead, and health provision in a plan has a separate duty-holder.)

There's a second, separate duty that's easy to overlook. Section 19 of the Education Act 1996 requires councils to arrange suitable full-time education (or as much as is in the child's interests, where their health means full-time isn't right for them) for any child of compulsory school age who, because of illness, exclusion or otherwise, may not receive suitable education unless those arrangements are made. It applies whether or not your child has an EHCP, and it doesn't switch off because an appeal has been lodged.

Where a child can't attend because of their health, including their mental health, the Department for Education's statutory guidance on children who cannot attend school because of health needs says councils should arrange education as soon as it's clear the child will be away for 15 school days or more, whether in one go or added up over the year. Not attending doesn't, on its own, settle the question; what the law asks is whether your child would otherwise receive a suitable education, which is why clear evidence of what's stopping them accessing school carries so much weight.

Appealing a plan that doesn't fit is something the law expects families to do, and it doesn't mean giving up any of the protection your child already has.

Offered isn't the same as accessible

Imagine buying a train ticket for someone who uses a wheelchair, to a station with no step-free access. The ticket is valid and the train is running, so on paper the journey is available. In practice, that person can't make it, and nobody would seriously argue they'd been given a way to travel.

The same thinking applies to education. Councils sometimes treat a named school place as proof that education is available, even when a child has been unable to attend for months because the environment has become too overwhelming for them. The courts have taken a more practical view. When deciding whether the Section 19 duty applies, the test they've set is whether the education on offer is actually available and accessible to the child, and whether it's reasonably practicable for them to attend it.

What this means for families is that if your child can't currently attend the school named in their plan, and you have evidence of why, the existence of a place there doesn't settle the question. The council has to consider whether it needs to make other arrangements so that your child receives a suitable education in the meantime, whether that's tuition at home, a smaller setting, online learning or a package built around what your child can manage at the moment.

For many of the children I see, the evidence of what school costs them shows up most clearly at home, in the exhaustion, the shutdowns and the evenings spent recovering, rather than in anything the school sees during the day. That's why it's worth recording what happens outside school as carefully as what happens inside it.

What the courts have said

These duties aren't new, and the High Court has looked at them several times in recent years:

  • LB v Surrey County Council (2022). The court looked at whether education was, in reality, available and accessible to a 15-year-old with complex needs, and found the council had failed to provide her with suitable interim education under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996. It also found breaches of the council's duties in relation to her EHCP.

  • HXN v London Borough of Redbridge (2024). The court explained that the Section 42 duty is to secure the provision in the plan, that it sits with the council rather than the school, and that trying to commission provision and actually delivering it are two different things. It ordered the council to put the provision in place.

  • L v Hampshire County Council (2024). The council accepted it had breached its duty after long gaps in a child's education otherwise than at school (EOTAS) package, nearly a year after the Tribunal had decided what his plan should say. Some support had been delivered, and the question for the court was what to order. It described the council's handling as "characterised by drift and delay" and ordered it to secure the provision.

  • JSH v Westmorland and Furness Council (2024). The court made clear that there's no "best endeavours" defence to the Section 42 duty. A council that has tried hard but not secured the provision has still not met its duty.

  • KGH v North Tyneside Council (2026). A more recent case in which the council had concluded that suitable education remained available at the child's school, which is a reminder that the courts look closely at the facts each time. What tends to make the difference is clear evidence of what's preventing a child from accessing education, and of what has actually been arranged.

Taken together, these cases say something consistent: education and support have to be real and reachable for the child, rather than described in a document or offered somewhere the child can't get to.

What you can do while the appeal goes ahead

Your appeal and these duties run alongside each other, so you don't have to choose between them. Some practical steps that families I work with have found useful:

  • Keep a simple record. Note which days your child attends or can't, what has been offered and when, and what happens after school and at weekends, including energy, mood and recovery time. This builds a clear picture of what your child can actually access, without you having to argue it from memory.

  • Put it in writing to the council. Explain that your child can't currently attend the named school, share the evidence you have, and ask the council to consider its duty under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996. It can help to send this to both the SEN team and the Director of Children's Services.

  • Ask what's happening with Section F. Ask the council how each part of the special educational provision in your child's current plan is being secured while the appeal is ongoing, and who is delivering it.

  • Use the complaints process if things don't move. If the council doesn't respond, or doesn't put arrangements in place, you can make a formal complaint. If that doesn't resolve it, the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman can investigate, find fault and recommend a remedy, though it may be limited in what it can look at while a connected appeal is still ongoing, so it's worth checking the timing with the Ombudsman before you complain. In some cases, where nothing else has worked, a specialist solicitor may be able to advise on whether judicial review is an option.

  • Think carefully before deregistering. If you're encouraged to home educate, it's worth knowing that elective home education means taking on responsibility for arranging and funding your child's education yourself, which is very different from the council arranging education under Section 19 or education otherwise than at school (EOTAS) through an EHCP. My piece EHE, Section 19 and EOTAS: Untangling the Confusion explains the difference, and there's no need to make that decision under pressure.

This piece is general information about the law, not legal advice about your child's situation, so if you're unsure what applies to you, it's worth getting advice before you act.

When conversations become harder

In my experience, the tone of meetings can shift once a family starts referring to these duties during an appeal. That's understandable, because it's often the point where the gap between what a plan says and what a child is actually receiving becomes hard to ignore, for everyone in the room.

Referring to the law calmly and in writing isn't being difficult, and it isn't at odds with working collaboratively with your child's school or the council. It gives everyone the same starting point. Many schools would welcome the council meeting its duties too, because they're often left trying to support a child without the resources the plan should have brought with it.

It can also help to keep the focus on your child rather than the dispute: what they can manage right now, what's getting in the way, and what would let them keep learning while the bigger questions are decided.

Why this is worth knowing now

Under the Government's SEND reform proposals, the Tribunal would no longer be able to name a school in a child's plan; it could only send the decision back to the council to look at again. Those proposals aren't law, and they may change. For families appealing today, though, it's a reminder of how much depends on the duties that already exist, and on families knowing they can rely on them.

A school place your child can't reach is a name on a piece of paper, and the law has always asked for more than that. Your child is entitled to an education they can actually access, today, whatever stage your appeal has reached.

Questions families often ask

Does appealing my child's EHCP stop the council's duties?

No. While the SEND Tribunal decides the appeal, the plan the council issued stays in force. The council must still secure the provision in Section F under Section 42 of the Children and Families Act 2014, and if your child can't currently access school, its duty under Section 19 of the Education Act 1996 still applies.

My child can't attend the school named in their EHCP. What can I do while we wait for a hearing?

Put it in writing to the council, share your evidence of why your child can't currently attend, and ask it to consider its Section 19 duty and to explain how each part of Section F is being secured. If nothing changes, you can make a formal complaint, and the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman may be able to look at it, although its role can be limited while a connected appeal is ongoing.

The council has suggested we home educate while we appeal. Do we have to?

No. A school can't force you to take your child off its roll, and elective home education means taking on responsibility for arranging and funding your child's education yourself. My piece on home education, Section 19 and EOTAS explains the difference in more detail.

The council says the provision is available at the named school, but my child can't get through the door. Is that enough?

Not on its own. The courts have looked at whether education is actually available and accessible to the child, and whether it's reasonably practicable for them to attend. A place your child can't currently reach, with evidence of why, doesn't by itself mean the council has met its Section 19 duty.

Do I have to keep sending my child to the named school while the appeal is going on?

The plan stays as it is until the Tribunal decides, so the named school remains the school in the plan. If your child can't attend because of their needs or health, keep a record of why, share it with the school and council in writing, and ask the council to consider Section 19, rather than letting the situation drift.

If you need support now

These free resources are based on the law as it stands today:

Sources

Previous
Previous

When a child suddenly wants to go back to school: a trauma-informed, neuroaffirming reflection

Next
Next

The Quiet Divide: How the SEND System Turns Parents and Schools into Opponents